same here eben jeorgi can get more then 10 trophies from me per raid this is unfair he is 5900 trophies and i am 5000 trophies player i dont know how trophies thing is working because i can aslo get only 9 to 10 trophies from jeorgi per raid this is unfair tho few peoples can get 9 trophies from me even they are 5300 trophies player they attack me simultaneolsy 3 times and all 3 times they can get 9 to 10 trophies and when i attack them i can get only 4 to 5 trophies from them per raid stupid trophies mechanism
Actually i play most matchmaker for about few days now. I notice if I lose too many raid or trophy from raiding, matchmaker will give me more trophy if I win. The most I have seen is around 35. That may explain why some people can gain 40-50 from my base. Because they have lost too many trophy from raiding, either trophy dump or bad luck.
I saw such 40 trophy opponents on match maker as well, and some of those have NEVER ever been attacked by me before. So I don’t think previous battles against the same person are the decisive factor here.
Also I have noticed that some players that are several hundred trophies above me and have much tougher bases than me got a 20 trophies for 80% raids on me, while I only see like 8 trophies from them (for 100% win).
Also I have seen bases give the same amount of trophies and medals no matter whether inside of an alliance (with like 6 or more elite boosts among most-used troop and structure types) or outside of an alliance (with 0 boosts).
Lately I really think the trophy/medal loot algorithm needs some reworking… raiding skill gets punished with worse and worse rewards for harder and harder matchmaking opponents while failing (and tropy dumping) with better own stats gets rewarded with tons of easy loot at same trophy level… that way it’s not only pay to win but also fail to prosper…